|Flaperon on a Boeing777|
MH370 UPDATE August 19 2015
[Later updates will appear here]
Julian Bray writes: Latest debris finds from the Maldives have been rejected. Metals not of 'airframe' quality. No interim report on the 'flaperon' so far. Unconfirmed stories of 'flaperon' part being deliberately placed, as manufacturers serial number tab or plate has been removed, and stencilled on service part number not a 'Boeing way of marking' says an insider.
SATURDAY AUGUST 8 2015
Julian Bray writes: Allegedly unhappy with the quality of the 'beachcombing' debris being passed over by the Malaysian authorities, the French investigating magistrate is planning a special trip to Malaysia, effectively ramping up French judiciary involvement in the current phase of the recovery operation surrounding missing Malaysia Airlines Flight 370.
The development is calling into question Malaysia’s criminal investigation, which has remained inconclusive, France is now starting its own triple method hunt for debris by air, land and sea over the region involving Réunion Island, French territory located in the western Indian Ocean. The first sortie was on Friday, but clearly the search will also be for small buoyant items such as seat squares, or indeed anything with the Malaysian branding on.
Malaysian officials are really furious that French investigators will still not fully confirm debris recovered so far (including the flaperon) is from the missing Boeing 777. A team of investigators led by Alain Gaudino, a French counter-terrorism magistrate examining the flaperon in Toulouse, isn’t taking any chances and has ordered more invasive tests. Julian Bray would also question the physical stencilled application of the 'part number' on the debris. It would not seem to be up to original Boeing standards but locally applied by an artisan!
The other 'fishy' detail is that it is claimed the original serial number plate or tag 'has fallen off.' Good grief! No I'm not for one moment suggesting black market parts sold without the original manufacturers serial number were being acquired and put on the MA fleet, but perhaps someone from Boeing can quickly explain how serial number identification can just 'fall off.' To be fair it could be a quirk of translation.
The French are treating this as a criminal investigation as French Nationals are also on the passenger list of the missing MH370.
French investigators have said the flaperon very likely came from the missing Boeing triple7. But they need undeniable evidence before they are willing to say 100% the flaperon broke off the actual Boeing 777er performing Flight MH370.
According to media sources, on Thursday Mr. Gaudino briefed Ghyslain Wattrelos,his wife, son and daughter were on the plane. The investigating magistrate told him an examination of the wing section didn’t yield confirmation it came from Flight MH370.
French investigators have already drilled into the recovered flaperon wing section, searching for signs of a maintenance seal or tag that Malaysian authorities documented when the missing jet previously underwent repairs.
The findings of the French investigators didn’t match the available Malaysian aircraft service records, Mr. Gaudino said, according to Mr. Wattrelos.
Malaysian officials, maintain the discrepancies aren’t significant enough to challenge their conclusion, according to two people familiar with the investigation but clearly any deviation does open up a whole raft of questions.
Malaysia’s transport minister said this week that paint on the wing section helped identify it as coming from the missing aircraft.
Mr. Gaudino maintains that the paint on the component appeared to come from its manufacturer, Boeing, not Malaysia Airlines, according to Mr. Wattrelos. It has also been highlighted that flaperons are also manufactured under a Boeing contract by a factory in Bangalore India, could this be a factory Flaperon reject, discarded and finally dumped in the Indian Ocean? Do they use Boeing sourced paint or buy a like specification locally?
“To my knowledge, there isn’t paint specific to Malaysia Airlines,” said a spokeswoman for Paris prosecutors who are working with Mr. Gaudino. "In addition, the wing section’s placard (tag or label) —containing an all important serial number—appears to have fallen off, the spokeswoman added.
To confirm the debris is from Flight 370, the team will now have to forensically examine the interior box section of the flaperon, compare serial numbers, and match them if possible to elements known to have been inside the Flight 370 flaperon.
Investigators are also trying to match documented data with an identifying mark on a portion of the internal structure that would conclusively establish the flaperon’s identity.
On Friday, France began a new search for plane debris in the seas surronding Réunion, it is expected to continue for 7 days. Réunion officials maintain they couldn’t yet identify new debris found on the island as coming from an airplane, directly contradicting broadcasted public statements from Malaysian officials that the objects are from an airplane.
Safety experts including Julian Bray from the UK fear that Malaysian authorities are prematurely announcing that debris has been found, only to amend and correct statements later on, effectively raising hopes for them only to be cruelly dashed. These announcements also effectively delay the core investigation.
Malaysian officials however promised to coordinate more closely with other nations after sustaining damaging widespread criticism for poor PR and multiple communication gaffs.
The Boeing 777, disappeared on March 8, 2014, en route from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing, is thought to have entered the eastern Indian Ocean, hundreds of miles away form the coast of Australia but technically and internationally agreed under Australian air traffic control. Weather experts say it is possible that ocean currents could have carried the debris from the possible crash location across the Indian Ocean to Réunion.
Australian officials are leading an extensive underwater search some 2,000 miles away from Réunion for the main wreckage of Flight MH 370, and the 'black boxes' [painted orange] recording flight data, also conversations and sounds in the cockpit.
Malaysian authorities investigated passenger and crew lists of MH370 last year, announcing in April 2014 that investigation had revealed nothing of interest and they had all been eliminated from the enquiry.
READ OUR EARLIER REPORTS:
Sources: AFP, WSJ, CNN, CNS, BBC, JBM. FRANCE24, ChannelNewsAsia, Singapore, BBC5Live, BBC Local Radio, GNS & LBC
JULIAN BRAY +44(0)1733 345581, Journalist, Broadcaster, Aviation Security & Operations Expert, Travel / Maritime & Cruise Industry, EQUITY, NUJ, Broadcast COOBE ISDN ++44 (0)1733 345020 (DUAL CODEC) SKYPE: JULIAN.BRAY.UK e&oe Cell: 07944 217476 or iPhone 0743 530 3145 www.aviationcomment.com # # # VENDOR 10476453 http://feeds.feedburner.com/BraysDuckhouseBlog